On Trump Until 2029 (4)

There is every reason to believe that Trump wants to make a grand bargain with Xi. It would include managed trade provisions and a division of the world into spheres of influence. It didn’t happen until now for two reasons: the Chinese would have been skeptical; and it would have torn the GOP apart.

Trump doesn’t care about party unity at this point, except to the extent that it is necessary to prevent impeachment, so the second reason for delay has disappeared. The first one probably still exists. We will find out soon enough.

On the Giant Who Leaves No Footprints

Russia and Ukraine belong to Kushner and Witkoff. The Middle East is the dynamic duo, plus J.D. and Hegseth. China is Bessent and Lutnick. What, you ask, is the portfolio of Marco Rubio? Isn’t he both the head of the NSC and the Secretary of State?

On paper, Marco has the same powers as Henry Kissinger at his height. In reality, his authority only extends to Latin America. That’s why he doesn’t get any blame for the war.

He’s the giant who leaves no footprints.

Trump Until 2029 (3)

Some commentators and a few Democrats have called for Trump to use his unique credibility with the base on immigration to make a Nixon-goes-to-China deal. It won’t happen; the base is too invested in hating immigrants, and in any event, Stephen Miller will be at Trump’s side. Whatever occasional ambivalence Trump may feel about protecting particularly useful immigrants, Miller has none.

The real question for the next two years is whether Trump and Miller will resume the army of occupation tactics that backfired so spectacularly in Minnesota in order to provoke a response that would merit the use of the Insurrection Act. Don’t be surprised if it happens. New York would be the obvious next target.

On Trump Until 2029 (2)

The script has flipped on Vladimir Putin. Until now, given his manpower advantage and the possibility of turning Trump completely against Ukraine, he had reason to believe that time was on his side. Today, the picture is different. Trump still has two years left, but he is on his way out, and his successor is likely to be far less accommodating to Russian interests. What does that mean for the immediate future?

Trump is unbound, and Le Pen, a potential ally, will probably be elected in the next few months. 2027 is the year for a great final diplomatic and military push to break up NATO and the EU and to subjugate Ukraine. How will Trump respond? With considerable sympathy, one imagines; he hates Ukraine, lacks any incentive to cooperate with the Russia hawks in his party, and sees plenty of commercial opportunity in changing sides.

On Trump Until 2029 (1)

The end of the midterms, even if the party in power loses, can be liberating in a sense for a lame duck president. He can look overseas to build his legacy with few limitations on his power. At home, he can pursue monumental bipartisan legislation to cement his reputation in the history books Is this what we can expect from Trump?

Of course not! Trump will feel empowered, not to work constructively with the opposition, but to indulge his worst impulses. He doesn’t care a fig for the future of the Republican Party. His primary objective will be to show the world that, his lame duck and election loser status notwithstanding, he’s still the boss, and his whims and caprices are still the law.

How will he do this? Over the next few days, I will count the ways.

On J.D., DeSantis, and the War

Donald Trump started the Iran war and still believes in it. The base despises the war and views it as a betrayal of “America First.” J.D. needs the support of both to get the nomination. As a result, he will have to turn himself into a pretzel on this issue; I predict he will blame the war on Israel and nonexistent American neocons in order to give Trump a pass.

DeSantis, to my knowledge, has not taken any strong positions on the war. He is consequently free to choose the one that will provide him with the most political benefit. What are his options, and which one will he pick?

He can try to endear himself to the base by opposing both the idea and the execution of the war, or he can appeal to the Haley voters by complaining solely about the execution, J.D.’s inept diplomatic efforts in particular. DeSantis absolutely has to have all of the Haley voters in his camp in order to win the nomination, so I’m guessing he will take the second option, and rely on other issues–AI in particular–to win over the required portion of the base.

On Trump’s China Plan

Trump 2.0 began by growling at China, but Xi retaliated with a rare earths ban, and Trump caved. Since then, Trump has focused his tariffs on everybody but China and has looked for nothing more than a sustained trade truce. What’s going on here? What’s the plan?

AI is the new silver bullet. It will, as Trump sees it, make America’s businesses more efficient than China’s. In addition, in the short run, the vast wave of AI investment is keeping Trump’s economy afloat in spite of the war and his tariffs. No wonder the man on golf cart stands with the tech barons against his own base.

The Jensen Huang scandal and resignation is thus a major blow to the Trump agenda. It isn’t simply that Trump identifies with a wealthy and powerful philanderer, even though he does; Huang is a driving force behind the AI revolution and its most eloquent cheerleader. AI optimists will have more trouble making their case to the public with his departure from the scene.

Project 2025 in 2027

The Heritage Foundation went all-in for Trump in 2024. Its “Project 2025” served as a blueprint for many of Trump’s acts of cultural, economic, and political demolition in the first half of his term. The American people noted their intense disapproval of Trump and his ideas during the midterms, which leaves Heritage in a difficult spot. Where will it go from here?

As I see it, Heritage has two choices: either distance itself from Trump the capricious authoritarian and insist that it only stands for its own reactionary ideas; or dive deeper into anti-democratic theories of government. The first would be a transparent and self-serving rewriting of history; the second is hardly likely to get much of a hearing from anyone outside of the extreme elements of the reactionary base in a country that appears to be rediscovering its liberal democratic roots.

On a Reagan-Trump Synthesis (2)

If you were a GOP candidate, how would you bridge the gap on immigration, trade, and the promotion of liberal democratic values? Here are my suggestions:

1. IMMIGRATION: Accept Trump’s efforts to control the border, but limit raids and deportations to dangerous criminals, and provide explicit protections short of full citizenship to Dreamers and other productive longtime residents. Liberalize legal immigration standards to meet needs for laborers in areas such as construction and elder care.

2. TRADE: Identify Chinese imports as the problem. Work with other countries throughout the world to reduce the Chinese trade surplus. Get rid of the other tariffs.

3. LIBERAL DEMOCRATIC VALUES: Support liberal democratic allies around the world. Promote universal human rights through publicity and diplomacy, but disclaim any desire to remake autocratic states through military force.

On a Reagan-Trump Synthesis (1)

Plenty of ink has been spilled about the differences between the Reagan and Trump wings of the GOP. What are these differences, and can they be synthesized?

The two wings actually agree on tax cuts for the wealthy, business deregulation, and a powerful military. They disagree on free trade, immigration, and the point of having the powerful military; Reagan wanted to use it to promote universal human rights, while Trump would deny that any such thing exists.

How can the differences on trade, immigration, and foreign policy be bridged? For that, see my next post.

On Rewriting Recent History

Oren Cass has been a vocal proponent of Trump’s tariff and deportation regime. He insisted, against all of the evidence, that a kindly and constructive Uncle Donald would pop out of nowhere and work with Congress to give his new economic scheme a permanent and reliable foundation. Now that Trump has been repudiated by the electorate, however, Cass is singing a different tune. He insists that Trumpism is a purely personal phenomenon with no consistent ideological content, that nothing new has actually been created after all of the destruction, and that the choice between Reaganite tax cutting and deregulation and New Right protectionism and interventionism will be made from scratch over the next few years.

This argument ignores two important facts. First of all, while it is certainly true that the most important component of Trumpism is the vicious and vindictive personality of the man on golf cart, mercantilism plays a significant part in it, as well. It was not for nothing that Cass steadfastly supported him until the electorate turned against him. Second, J.D., the leader of the Godly Society element of the administration, relies heavily on Trumpian anger and capriciousness to keep all of the factions in line; he also supported Trump’s “Reaganite” line of cutting taxes for the rich and deregulating AI.

In short, the battle lines between the New Right and the Reaganites are not as clear in the real world as Cass makes them out to be, and Trump’s failures are partially attributable to the New Right policies that Cass espouses.

On J.D., the Base, and 2028

J.D. clearly believes the war is the greatest obstacle to a successful campaign for the nomination in 2028. He is undoubtedly correct; if the war, with its corresponding increase in prices, is still going on in 2028, he will be toast. But what if it isn’t? Is he home free?

The road map to beating J.D. requires one of his competitors to peel off about 25 percent of the base and to win all of the Haley vote. Even without the war, J.D.’s hold on the base is shaky on the following issues: AI/Big Tech/data centers; tariffs; and his marriage to Usha. Could that amount to 25 percent of the base?

In my opinion, yes. There is a lane for DeSantis if he has the nerve and the mental agility to take it.

On the Merits of the Massie Impeachment Articles

The Constitution does not contemplate impeachment for incompetence. Thomas Massie knows that, which is why his articles are grounded in alleged violations of statutes and the Constitution. That approach is legally appropriate.

The problem with most of his articles is that Hegseth was doing what Trump told him to do. That means, not just that he can plead the following orders defense, but that the rest of the GOP will rally around both him and Trump. As a practical matter, therefore, his articles are mostly doomed to fail.

The obvious exception is the allegation about attempting to prosecute Mark Kelly. That article has constitutional implications and cannot be tied directly to Trump. It also appeals to the self-interest of members of Congress. Its chances are much better.

I don’t know why Massie didn’t include an allegation about the mishandling of classified information, which would go beyond mere incompetence and cannot be attributed to Trump. If his articles fail, the Democrats would be wise to include it in a subsequent resolution after the end of the year.

Personally, I would say the real issue with Hegseth is his desire to politicize the military on Trump’s behalf, but I would acknowledge it might be difficult to prove that allegation.

When Trump Becomes “Trump”

J.D. accepts the GOP nomination for president in 2028.

“I’m proud to have Donald Trump’s endorsement for president. He is the very embodiment of the values of MAGA. In particular, he believes that America should take care of its own first, and avoid unnecessary foreign wars, most notably in the Middle East.

I know, I know, you’re saying he actually started a war with Iran. But he didn’t do that. It was Bibi, and Israel, and the neocons that did it! That’s right–they’re still around. Jewish neocons. They were hovering around our administration like vultures. They sold him a bill of goods, and in a moment of blindness, he bought it. But he didn’t mean to, and it won’t happen again.

Donald Trump will always put America first. He knows now that he can’t trust the Israelis and the neocons. And so do I. There will be no wasteful foreign wars, and no neocons, in my administration.”

On 1866 and 2026

Andrew Johnson campaigned vigorously for a program of reactionary presidential Reconstruction in the 1866 midterms. His efforts failed completely. The power to mold Reconstruction passed from the executive to the Radical Republicans in Congress, an unsuccessful impeachment ensued, and the rest is history.

It sounds a bit like last week, no? Except that Johnson was an accidental president without a faithful base, so the ultimate outcome of the coming battle between the two branches of the federal government is likely to be quite different.