I attribute the events at Cornell to three factors: first, the perennial problem with fraternity culture, which existed long before I was born; second, the impacts of social media, which put the “gang” in gangbang; and third, the permission slip we gave for this kind of behavior when we elected a man found liable for sexual assault as our head of state. Trump has already expressed more concern for the due process rights of the male participants than for the feelings of the victim. Are you surprised?
The criminal law is a blunt instrument, and the facts are murky here, so the new investigation has to be done with great care. It is highly unlikely that all of the participants are equally culpable; some of them may not be guilty of criminal acts at all. What we can say with confidence, however, is that all of the participants treated the victim like a piece of meat. Anyone who was aware of what was going on and did nothing to stop it deserves our condemnation even if the criminal law is not applied.