It isn’t just Oren Cass; the entirety of the New Right, it seems, is out of love with Donald Trump. The “America First” crowd hates the war; bigots think Trump has been soft on immigrants and dislike his close relationship with Israel; protectionists have concerns about his erratic use of tariffs; economic populists are upset about the uncritical embrace of AI and tax cuts for the wealthy: and Christian fundamentalists complain that he has done nothing to stop abortion. It’s a record of nothing but betrayals.
That’s what happens when you hitch your star to a capricious despot who values his own interests and his status as the world’s boss over any ideology. But what about J.D.? Does this mean he is toast, too?
J.D. will win the nomination if he keeps the populist right in his corner. Look for him to run hard against the Reaganite remnants of his party in the primaries; he will try to reconcile with them in the general election by focusing on culture war issues and the dangers presented by the left.
It can work if the public perceives that America is secure, prosperous, and at peace by 2028. That could happen, but I wouldn’t hold my breath.