Four Thoughts on the Eviction Moratorium

Here are my thoughts:

  1. Biden’s initial response was correct; extending the moratorium isn’t the best solution to the problem. There is plenty of money available for tenants and landlords; the challenge is to get state and local governments to distribute it.
  2. Nevertheless, Biden’s hands were tied as soon as Pelosi came out strongly in favor of the extension. He owes her too much to ignore her.
  3. The new regulation is not a Trumpian attempt to defy a court order; it is a good faith effort to accomplish a legitimate public health objective, while acknowledging the limits put on his powers by the Supreme Court.
  4. In the end, the legal argument will probably fail, but no one can say he didn’t try, and he will have bought some time for a real solution.

On Politics and the Culture War (2)

Some reactionary commentators argue that the right has to fight culture with politics because the deck is stacked against them. Is that really true?

No. Let’s break it down:

  1. Most people under 50 today get their news and ideas from the internet, which is a right-wing playground;
  2. The right has its own, very popular TV network, and, in any event, most of the people who watch the news on broadcast TV are elderly Trump voters;
  3. The left has the NYT, but only a small number of people read it. The right has the WSJ;
  4. There are plenty of periodicals on both sides; and
  5. Hollywood is more interested in making money than in scoring ideological points. Rupert Murdoch used to own one of the studios, but he sold it.

The bottom line is that the reactionary right is losing the culture war for two other reasons. First, the principal opinion-makers on the right are more interested in tax cuts than Dr. Seuss. Second, younger Americans are concerned about rising inequality, the dollar store economy, bigotry, and climate change. The right has nothing to offer on any of these points; it even denies that climate change exists. Why would anyone under 30 embrace the right under these circumstances?

On Politics and the Culture War (1)

As I’ve noted many times before, the reactionary right is attempting to use the political system to crush popular leftish ideas instead of putting its resources into winning the intellectual debate. Assuming, for purposes of argument, that the right has the political and legal muscle to impose some degree of censorship on the left, can this approach actually work in the long run?

History says no. It didn’t even work in totalitarian states prior to the advent of the internet. Given the practical difficulties involved in controlling the web, and the libertarian strains of reactionary thought, how can the right completely stifle the woke left, even under unrealistically favorable circumstances?

On the GOP, UI, and the Vaccine

Republicans are determined to provide business with a docile, low-paid workforce, so they naturally hate unemployment insurance. They do their best to keep payments to their absolute minimum, and to make the system as hard to navigate as possible. DeSantis even admitted that Rick Scott had done that in the early stages of the pandemic.

But Republicans love the unvaccinated members of their base. What happens when these people start getting laid off for violating employer vaccine mandates? Will the GOP intervene to make sure they get paid in spite of their insubordination?

My guess is that the donor class will prevail over the base on this one, but it will be a dilemma, to be sure.

On Business and the Orban Option

In a truly fascist regime, business remains in private hands, but is strictly regulated in the interests of the nation. Illiberal democracies are quite different. In an illiberal democracy, the government compels businessmen to stand in line, suck up, and compete for favors. It is a system that more closely resembles feudalism than democratic capitalism.

Putin practically invented this system. Orban does it, too. We had a glimpse of it in this country, with Trump’s whimsical tariffs and exceptions.

So how would businesses respond to the Orban Option in America? Opinion would be divided. Many small business owners are ideological Reactionaries and would have nothing to fear from arbitrary interventions, so they would probably welcome the new regime. History tells us in any event that small business owners are typically the backbone of reactionary governments, regardless of the time and place. Larger corporations would be much less enthusiastic—particularly tech businesses. Anyone with strong interests in international trade and a liberal workforce is going to run into trouble with a regime that celebrates and protects the past, not the present and the future.

On Infrastructure and the Debt Ceiling

About 40 percent of our GOP senators are poised to vote for a large new dose of public spending. Does that mean we can count on them to be responsible and support a debt ceiling increase? Is the next crisis over before it began?

To refuse to lift the debt ceiling is nihilism under the best of circumstances. In the current environment, it would be throwing gas on a fire. In addition, voting to hold the country hostage for spending cuts after supporting a massive new spending program would be an act of breathtaking hypocrisy.

Don’t bet it won’t happen.

On Orban and Immigration

If Viktor Orban had his way, he would probably build a wall around his entire country—not just to keep the dirty foreigners out, but to hold his young, talented people in. Unfortunately for him, he needs EU money to keep his country afloat and line his friends’ pockets, so the wall isn’t a real possibility. What can he do?

Well, he has plenty of appeal to the GOP, so why not persuade them to immigrate? Rod Dreher is already there. Why not Tucker, or even Trump?

It would work for everyone, including us.

Last Thoughts on the Olympics

For better or worse, watching the Olympics is an intense experience for me. I don’t watch the Closing Ceremonies, because they only remind me that there is a void in my life that needs to be filled.

Otherwise, here are my last thoughts on the games:

  1. The US and China basically engage in different competitions. The Chinese are bit players in swimming, track, and team sports, while we don’t care about the sports they dominate. As a result, you almost never see close, dramatic confrontations between athletes of the two countries. Our real rivals are Australia and Jamaica.
  2. The pandemic made a difference. China and island nations that mostly kept the virus out clearly had an advantage over us.
  3. I did a thought experiment which led me to realize that I have more vivid memories of the 1972 than the 2016 Olympics. I think there is a message in there about youth and consciousness. What will we remember about Tokyo, besides the pandemic? Probably the Biles fiasco, the failures of our sprinters, KD bailing out our basketball team, and the successes of our swimmers. Time will tell.

Sympathy for the Unvaccinated?

You see it every day: prominent reactionary GOP politicians fighting for the right to spread the virus; parents demonstrating at school board meetings against mask mandates; faux libertarians screaming about personal freedom on TV. These same people, of course, lead the charge against freedom of choice on abortion. It’s enough to make you want to throw up.

But we are being told that most vaccine doubters are actually victims, and can be reached by a better vaccination program. In other words, it’s Biden’s fault. Do you buy that?

Consider the following common justifications for not getting the vaccine:

  1. I’m uninsured, and I don’t believe the vaccine is free: Well, it is, and you have been told that by the government and the media from the beginning;
  2. I can’t take time off work: Then make an appointment for after work. Pharmacies are open after 5:00;
  3. I don’t have transportation: So how do you get to work and the grocery store?
  4. It’s not proven to be safe: How many people have did from the vaccine, as opposed to the virus?

The bottom line is that there is no good reason to refuse the vaccine. It’s time for mandates—period.

On DeSantis and Dissonance

Around the beginning of the year, Ron DeSantis was fairly energetic in his efforts to get his elderly and relatively affluent supporters vaccinated. Since then, not so much. DeSantis has emerged as one of the national leaders in the battle to protect the rights of the unvaccinated to make the rest of us sick and curtail our freedoms. At this point, it would be fair to call him the best friend of the virus.

Perhaps the virus should be his running mate in 2022.

When DeSantis is asked about the inevitable explosion of cases in Florida, he either blames illegal immigrants or shouts indignantly that we aren’t going to have any more lockdowns. The first is demonstrably false; the latter is logically absurd, as the whole point of mandates is to avoid lockdowns.

Now, DeSantis apparently has a plan to kill two birds with one stone by offering children who refuse to comply with public school mask mandates vouchers for private schools. What a great idea! I can’t think of any better way to discredit voucher schemes than to turn private schools into virus incubators.

Just imagine: masks could be the new form of segregation in Florida schools.

On Mitch and the Orban Option

Mitch McConnell, to his credit, is not a counterrevolutionary. Why should he be? His agenda consists of shoving business tax cuts and conservative judges through the system. He can do that today without blowing up the system. Hence, his apparently sincere condemnation of Trump and the rioters after January 6.

The problem for Mitch is that he has lost control of the GOP to Trump and the culture war right. There is no obvious role for Mitch and the PBPs once the Reactionaries have imposed the Orban Option. He and the donor class will just have to shut up and hope for the best.

Does Mitch understand that a GOP dominated by the extreme right is as dangerous to him and his business constituents as the left? Does he have a plan for heading it off?Mitch is no fool, so I’m guessing the answer is yes.

On Denmark and Hungary

Bernie Sanders was very open about it during the 2020 campaign; he wanted America to look like Denmark. Denmark is an impeccable liberal democracy with better public services and less inequality than we do. It also has higher taxes, a little less personal freedom, and fewer incentives for excellence than we do. Which system works better is a matter of personal taste.

For most of history, the American right would have recoiled at the notion that a foreign nation should serve as a role model. Today, with America a lost cause (as they see it), the reactionary right has embraced Hungary as the New Jerusalem. Hungary is a land characterized by a declining population, rampant corruption starting at the top, a rigged electoral system, a totally politicized judicial system, and mediocre growth rates. Reactionaries love it for all of that because Orban is a vibrant nationalist and culture warrior.

Which country sounds more appealing? You decide.

On Trump and the Orban Option

Trump proved during the 2020 campaign that he has no policy ideas, only whims and prejudices. As a result, if he runs in 2024, his “platform” will be to turn America into Hungary by destroying liberal democracy. He has nothing else to say.

But remember, he is a man on golf cart, not horseback. If he wins, he may well be too lazy, disorganized, and vain to get the job done, unlike some of his other GOP compatriots.

So there is the irony: the most likely instrument of our destruction may actually, in the end, prove to be the downfall of the Orban Option.