On Chinese Contradictions

The success of the Chinese government over the foreseeable future will depend largely on its ability to resolve, or at least paper over, the following contradictions:

  1.  The ideal:  Marxism, a Western ideology with universal values.  The reality:  Chinese exceptionalism.
  2.   The ideal:  Marxism, a dynamic, forward-looking ideology.  The reality:  A culture that attaches great value to harmony and stability.
  3.  The ideal:  A decentralized, consumer-driven economy.  The reality:  Very extensive government intervention in the economy to promote stability and maintain a monopoly on power.
  4.  The ideal:  An economy that promotes innovation.  The reality:  Minimal respect for property rights for parties without government connections and severe limits on the free flow of information.
  5.   The ideal:  Encourage investment through a predictable system of taxation and commercial law.  The reality:   Government retains arbitrary powers; capital flees the country.
  6.  The ideal:  Eliminate endemic corruption.  The reality:  A one-party system, a politicized judicial system, and no freedom of the press.
  7. The ideal:  Accommodate Hong Kong and Taiwan by tolerating different systems.  The reality:  Intolerance of democratic ideas in Hong Kong hardly encourages the notion of an improvement of relations with Taiwan.